There’s something magnetic about Sag Harbor.
Maybe it’s the way the boats bob in the harbor just steps from Main Street. Or how a historic whaling village somehow became one of the chicest spots on the East End. Whether you’re visiting for the first time or just looking to fall in love with Sag all over again, this guide is your go-to for making the most of your day.
Here’s everything I’d do if I had one perfect Sag Harbor day—from the best restaurants to the most charming things to do.
🌿 Where to Eat in Sag Harbor
Sag Harbor punches well above its weight in the restaurant department. You’ll find everything from candlelit pasta dinners to dockside lobster rolls, plus buzzy wine bars and longtime local favorites. Here are some of my top picks:
Lulu Kitchen & Bar – A Hamptons classic with an open kitchen and wood-fired everything. Great for brunch, lunch, or a lively dinner with friends.
Tutto il Giorno – Elegant coastal Italian with a garden patio that feels like a hidden oasis. The perfect date night spot.
Bell & Anchor – Slightly off the beaten path but worth the drive for oysters, lobster rolls, and a cozy neighborhood vibe.
Beacon – Come for the sunset, stay for the swordfish. One of the best waterfront views in the Hamptons. Pro tip: book well in advance.
DOPO La Spiaggia – An upscale Italian experience with beautifully plated dishes and an intimate setting.
The Dock House – Classic seafood shack energy with walk-up ordering and unbeatable harbor views. Casual, nostalgic, and delicious.
Vin Sur Vingt – A French wine bar with small plates and a scene. Great for a slow afternoon glass of rosé.
Sag Harbor Tavern – Laid-back and family-friendly with pub-style fare and live music in the summer.
Page at 63 Main – Farm-to-table and always fresh. There’s also a speakeasy-style cocktail bar tucked downstairs.
Le Bilboquet – Chic, elevated, and definitely a scene. If you’re craving upscale French vibes, this is your spot.
The American Hotel – Steeped in history, this white-tablecloth dining room delivers classic service and a clubby, timeless feel.
Il Capuccino – Old-school red sauce charm with big portions and garlic knots that deserve their own fan club.
🌸 What to Do in Sag Harbor
You don’t need a big agenda to enjoy Sag—just walking around with an iced coffee in hand can feel like a summer dream. But if you’re looking to fill your day, here are a few favorite things to do:
Grab a coffee and croissant at Carissa’s – A light, flaky start to your day in Sag.
Visit the Sag Harbor Whaling Museum – A quick, fascinating dive into the town’s nautical past, housed in a stunning 1845 mansion.
Catch a show at Bay Street Theater – This waterfront venue hosts Broadway-quality plays and concerts all summer long.
Spend a beach day at Long Beach – Calm waters and easy access make it a favorite for families and relaxed afternoon dips.
Stroll and shop along Main Street – You’ll find high-end boutiques, independent bookshops, curated home stores, and hidden vintage gems.
Grab ice cream at Big Olaf’s – A Sag Harbor rite of passage. Bonus points if you get it in a waffle cone.
Watch the sunset at Beacon – It’s a whole vibe. Boats pulling in, golden light on the water, a chilled glass of wine in hand.
Try Grindstone’s legendary donuts – Cider-glazed, maple bacon, or just plain old-fashioned. They’re worth the hype.
Catch live music at Kidd Squid Brewing Co. – Sag’s local craft brewery with a laid-back vibe and weekend performances.
Explore the latest exhibition at The Church – This reimagined space for art and community, housed in a former church, always surprises with thoughtful programming.
✨ Final Thoughts
Sag Harbor is one of those rare places that feels both timeless and current. It’s a town where history lives next to high design, where locals and weekenders blend seamlessly, and where every summer day feels a little cinematic.
Whether you’re coming for the croissants, the culture, or just a slow stroll by the boats, Sag never disappoints.
Bookmark this post or send it to your summer crew—this is one Hamptons day trip you’ll want to plan right.